Currently our Data Network is engineered to provide equal access
to our Internet 1 between all faculty, staff, and student needs at the
University of Kansas. Our I1 traffic is now pegged at maximum usage between
the hours of 7am to 2am daily with most traffic generated by on-campus
housing. The non-academic utilization of current bandwidth severely impacts
our institution’s ability to use this valuable resource for academic
and administrative purposes.
Recently, a plethora of new applications (IMESH, Kazaa, eDonkey, etc.) have become available. These applications
make it easy for people throughout the Internet to locate and exchange
information. This Fall more residents than ever have begun doing this
(knowingly and unknowingly -- some applications make files on your PC
accessible to anyone by default). How do these packages work? Users
of these applications send queries for a particular piece of content
(e.g. an MP3 from Phish's latest album) and then are automatically
connected to an individual’s computer, which contains that file.
Due to the connection speeds involved, university student systems (not
limited to just KU) tend to be highly used by Internet users with no
affiliation to the university. This consumes valuable Internet bandwidth
and benefits no one at the university (including the resident) . We
are examining the problem in depth and making recommendations to both
improve connectivity and manage/support our bandwidth. How do we implement
a fair method of protecting everyone's resources? Some of the potential
solutions are:
-
Do nothing. If we do nothing, internet users unaffiliated with the
University of Kansas will soak up all available ResNet bandwidth until
the system becomes unusable. This is the approach of some "broadband"
service providers. ResNet's mission, however, is to provide high quality
network services to its residents. Therefore, we find this solution
unacceptable.
-
Charge everyone more money to cover for those using excessive non-academic
bandwidth. The problem with charging everyone more money, is
that the bandwidth demand from the rest of the Internet to ResNet is
potentially infinite. An individual on ResNet may only download a limited
amount of content, but the Internet, with hundreds of millions of users,
always has someone wanting the latest Madonna song and ready to download
it using our high speed connections. It doesn't take too many users
like this before it becomes obvious that residents could not afford
to foot the bill for this non-academic use.
-
Charge based on the bandwidth used. We are exploring the technical
and policy implications of this and hope to offer it as an option at
some point. This is the solution universities often use to allocate
limited resources. The allowed bandwidth usage per user under this scenario
would still be limited, because we are limited by the length of contracts
we must enter into and state purchasing rules, etc.
-
Limit the aggregate bandwidth to the on-campus residents during peak
usage times. This solution will address the problem immediately and
allow the university mission to support our academic and administrative
needs with some relief. We will continue to research other alternatives
as we and many colleges and universities face this problem.